Combat! reviews by Jo
Davidsmeyer
Episodes rated from 0 to 4 bayonets
(026)
No Hallelujahs for Glory
1.5 bayonets
First aired: 03-19-63
Syndication order: 26
Season: One, Episode 24
Teleplay by Luther Davis and Mort R. Lewis
Story by Luther Davis
Directed by Paul Stanley
Produced by Paul Stanley
Review
I grit
my teeth through much of this episode: the portrayal of Eleanora Hunt, a professional
female journalist, is so condescending and negative. She's grating, bitchy, ignorant
about her assigned topic (the military), and difficult to believe as a realistic
character. Incompetent as a reporter and uncooperative with her sources, I don't
understand how she achieved her high level of success in her chosen profession. She's
looked down upon by all the men in the show, who do everything short of saying that what
she needs is a good roll in the hay. The moral of the story seems to be that if women
would just remember their place and stop trying to prove they're better than men, then
innocent people won't get killed.
We can blame this story on Luther Davis, who brought us the lackluster episode
"The Quiet Warrior." Paul Stanley, as director and producer, salvages this
episode with some stark visuals and memorable images. The opening sequence showing
Eleanora's photos of men on the front is charming. The final sequence showing Saunders
reading her photo-article is devastating. And in be- tween, Stanley lets us be more
horrified by our imaginations than by anything he can show us. We do not see the corpses
in the room after the S.S. has finished their interrogation, only the reac- tions of
Saunders and Hunt to seeing them. The shadow of the gallows with its three victims and the
anguished reactions of the crowd speak volumes more than any graphic shot of corpses dangling by their necks.
Jason and Morrow interact nicely in this episode. Both also have strong scenes with
Elizabeth Allen (Eleanora): in the town Hanley is forceful with her, about to throw the
uncooperative reporter over his shoulder and carry her off. Saunders is partic- ularly
abusive (verbally) with her. No PPT, just derision. Of course, the stupid character as
written deserves the abuse.
Notes, Oddities, and Bloopers
- Saunders is introduced as Hanley's platoon
sergeant. Must have been a temporary assignment (obviously the platoon sergeant de jour
had been recently killed)
- Morrow caught in the act in the first
briefing scene! I've often noticed how in two-shots with Saunders and Hanley, or Saunders
and any number of taller guest stars, and even two- shots with Saunders and Littlejohn,
Saunders seems to manage to be on eye-level with the other actor. You almost never catch
him in the act, though. In the briefing scene in the woods, however, you can clearly see
him walk to his mark and step UP on a rock (and later step down when the scene is over).
- Another Canadian character spotted! That
makes two. Not much to represent the efforts of the Canadian forces in WWII.
- Some unusually graphic one-on-one killings
as the squad re- enters the town, except for Billy, who we don't see commit the act.
- Times change, Caje mentions that Eleanora
would have gotten 10 years back in the states for stealing the jeep. Now you get a slap on
the wrist for grand theft auto.
- Caje appears wounded when the jeep is
attacked (he's sprawled forward and not firing when poor Kirby is alone trying to fight
off the Germans). But he's perfectly fine in the next scene.
- Kirby with that darned M1 again.
- I like Hanley trying to hide his laughter at
Saunders' crack to Captain about "No submarines around here."
- a very annoying "flashback" in the
final scene. Were they afraid we weren't paying attention and had to have the message beat
into our heads?
Cast Credits
Rick Jason
as Lt. Hanley
Vic Morrow
as Sgt. Saunders
Guest Star
Elizabeth Allen as Eleanora Hunt
Jack Hogan as Kirby
Dick Peabody as Littlejohn
Pierre Jalbert as Caje
Steven Rogers as Doc
Tom Lowell as Billy
Angela Clarke .... Mme. Michelin
George Petrie .... Captain Smith
Charles McDaniel .... Bearded Correspondent
Garry Walberg .... Thin Correspondent
Maurice Marsac .... Jacques
James Goodwin .... Mike
Related Reading about war correspondents
Reporting World War II:
American Journalism 1938-1946
The work of more than 50 remarkable reporters has been drawn from
original newspaper and magazine reports, radio transcripts, and wartime books to capture
the intensity of WWII's unfolding drama. Stories by Ernie Pyle, E. B. White, John
Steinbeck, Edward R. Murrow, Martha Gellhorn, James Agee, John Hersey - whose Hiroshima
appears in full -and many more. Also includes a detailed chronology (1933-1945), maps,
journalist profiles, and a glossary of military terms. At 874 pages, this is a huge volume
packed with incredible eye-witness reports.
List price $18.95.
Check price at
Amazon.com
Amazon.ca
Also available in hardcover:
Check price at
Amazon.com
Amazon.ca
|
|